Band in a Box Update for Mac

User Reviews

• BIAB for Mac 2014 and Support fail to deliver

  daholl5September 15, 2014

  Pros

  BIAB is a great idea.

  Cons

  Despite its potential, BIAB is an expensive product that does not live up to claims. Key features described in ads and the manuals simply do not work reliably or at all. I experienced dropouts in Rendered Audio files; Bar Settings did not work; Song Endings did not play as programed; Pushes (anticipations) Holds and Kicks did not work properly; certain combinations of Styles consistently triggered crashes. When I contacted Support at first they said they'd never experienced or heard of any of the problems I reported. I did 3 re-installations a spent a month of sending files and trying a series of supposed "fixes" and workarounds, none of which worked. It became apparent that Support had not actually tested the "sure fix" solutions. Soon excuses began to be substituted for solutions. Finally they confessed that they couldn't fix the problems and told me I should accept the "limitations" of the product. Since then there has been NO followup or news of any progress.

  Summary

  PG's literature exaggerates the program's actual capabilities. It is a very expensive half-baked BETA. Either the developers did not test BIAB before releasing it or they just rushed it to market without concern for obvious problems and limitations. Personally, I find it hard to believe that the developers and support team were truly unaware of them. PG Music may be a small company but at the prices customers are paying they have a right to expect more than excuses and apologies.

  ---

• Still not fixed

  jeffhrsnJanuary 21, 2009

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />PG Music programmers are obviously Windows-centric. This is easily one of the ugliest, most ridiculously laid out program on the Macintosh. The installer still ignores Apple's guidelines YEARS after PG Music's knowing this. Wishing someone else would come along and blow these guys out of the water - they truly deserve it.

  ---

• not funny

  winnertakesallNovember 28, 2004

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />Build 22 simply refuses to install, claiming some files are missing and requiring that I reinstall the programme. How can that be if build 21 worked perfectly ? Alt., the installer tells me to "rebuidl the desktop" !! In Mac OS X, imagine !! It would be funny if it wasn't sad :-((

  ---

• One off the funniest program I have tried

  crister.skoglund_dotmacJuly 14, 2004

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />At last there is a native OSX version of this old classic. And the program has now developed and get enriched so the possible variations are endless. (I have been using it since version 5, but not so much the last years since it only ran in Classic) Now however it runs perfectly in OSX and files can be saved both in the programs own format and as MIDI files. The only thing I am missing is an easy way to change files with Garageband. Now the only solution I have found is to save the compleated song in MIDI format, then use Dent de Midi to transform it into tracks that can be imported into Garageband for further modification. There are also a few small bugs in the list editing module I think (or I am doing something wrong) but otherwise it is a very stable program. Crister

  ---

• crummy demo

  goalieJune 27, 2004

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />After I downloaded the demo on Friday the 25th of June, I got a messages "reminding" me that it would expire on the 1st of July! Then when I took time to start it up, I found that despite their ballyhooing the new OS X version (12), the demo is an old Classic program. The "about" box says it's version 11, but the Web page whence you download the demo says "This demo is from version 8 of Band-in-a-Box for Macintosh." <p> Not only that, but several aspects of this old V.8 or V.11 program are disabled, including notation -- one aspect I was most wanting to try. <p> I guess I'll just give Band-in-a-Box up as a bad job, never knowing what the actual OS X program is like.

  ---

• UI needs work...

  dylanw_dotmacJune 25, 2004

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />... and has for a long time. BiaB isn't the best at what it does, but it's the only one that does it. The UI hasn't had a serious update since v.6. It doesn't really feel like an OS X program (hell, it doesn't really feel like a Mac program). Adding styles is a non-trivial task, and the style editor doesn't seem to have been updated for <i>years</i>. But it does seem to work, so I give it credit for that.

  ---

• Worth Waiting For

  hrubin1000June 25, 2004

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />Nicely integrated with Core MIDI

  ---

• Ooooooh!

  cukJune 24, 2004

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />Yessss!!!!!

  ---

• stugOctober 7, 2002

  Pros

  Cons

  Summary

  This review was originally posted on VersionTracker.com.<br />BIAB is a great product for musicians who want to take their comping/soloing to a higher level (not only for keyboard or guitar !). Especially

  ---