• On MovieTome: See the villain of IRON MAN 2!
The Download Blog
advertisement
July 23, 2008 5:51 PM PDT

New Reviews: The Mac uninstallers

by Jason Parker
New Reviews(Credit: CNET Networks)

As a software reviewer, I download a lot of programs to test them out. Some are great programs deserving of a space on my hard drive while others just are not up to snuff. With all the available software here at CNET Download.com, you've probably found a few gems worth keeping, but you've inevitably also downloaded a few programs that just didn't work out. We understand.

On a Windows machine, you can go to the control panel and choose the Add/Remove programs tool to find and uninstall software you don't want. But on a Mac, it's not as easy. When you install on a Mac the process usually involves dragging the software into your Applications folder. What you may not know is other files associated with that program are automatically installed into different folders to make the program work properly. So if you simply drag that app icon to the trash, you're leaving a significant amount of unused files on your hard drive.

Today, we have a group of freshly reviewed apps whose purpose is to extricate those unwanted apps and leftover files from your hard drive. They come in a few different versions, but all are worthy of checking out if you want to trash that one program once and for all, or if you just need to make space on your hard drive.

AppTrap is less of an app than it is a free System Preference pane. Once set up (you can have AppTrap start at login), all you need to do is exactly what you've probably done all along: drag the application to the trash. When you do, AppTrap will ask if you want to delete all associated files. Simply answer yes and you're done. If you're looking for the least work to get your Mac apps off your hard drive, AppTrap is your program.

AppCleaner(Credit: CNET Networks)

AppCleaner is a free program that lets you be a little more hands-on than AppTrap. You can drag unwanted apps to the nice-looking interface, or browse through a list of possible apps to uninstall. AppCleaner shows you all the files you will be deleting before your confirmation so make sure to look closely before you pull the trigger.





AppZapper(Credit: CNET Networks)

AppZapper is a shareware program I've talked about before and does a fairly good job, but it will cost you ($12.95). Like AppCleaner you can drag-and-drop apps to the interface to display associated apps. But AppZapper also offers the UnZap command, letting you retrieve previously "zapped" software components from the trash. As an added bonus, you can also have the program search for other trash files on your hard drive with the Genie.

CleanApp(Credit: CNET Networks)

CleanApp is another shareware alternative with a few extra features than AppZapper, and yet it's more affordable ($10). CleanApp offers the same drag-and-drop functionality, but also allows you to track all future installations so you can make absolutely sure you delete every file upon uninstallation. CleanApp seems to forever remain in beta, but does a nice job otherwise and might be just the solution you're looking for.

Not all downloads are good downloads. Unfortunately, when you're on a Mac, it's more difficult to completely extract all files associated with unwanted software. Check out our reviews and look at the available features before installing the uninstaller that's right for you.

Recent posts from The Download Blog
Create photo presentations and race 4x4s off road: iPhone apps of the week
Chrome OS for the clueless: What it means for real people
Manage multiple Twitter accounts with your iPhone
Silverlight 3 debuts ahead of Friday's launch
Selected Search speeds up on-page searching
Android ringtone swap: First Look video
Archive your e-mail from almost any account
An epitaph for the Web standard, XHTML 2
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (13 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by b_baggins July 25, 2008 9:00 AM PDT
OS X is not Windows.

99% of the time the files scattered all over the place, are actually put in your home/library folder and don't bother anything or anybody, unlike tangled spaghetti registry entries which can hose an entire Windows system.

In other words, it doesn't matter if you leave the files there unless you're the kind of person who want to save 500k of space on your 250GB hard drive.
Reply to this comment
by jparker July 25, 2008 12:12 PM PDT
I see what you're saying b_baggins, but if you're going to uninstall the app, doesn't it make sense to uninstall it completely? That's great if the extra files don't hurt your system, but why not get rid of them if you're never going to use them?
Reply to this comment
by b_baggins July 28, 2008 7:23 AM PDT
No reason at all. Except that these tools usually cost money.
by cybercuz2 July 25, 2008 6:45 PM PDT
Just how many of these 4 kb files would I have to delete to make room for one of these programs I'm going to use to delete 4 kb text filebs that do not hurt a thing where they are ?.. They are not registry entries or dll files that might cause a problem with other files and cause a system crash like on a PC....
Reply to this comment
by raw_knee July 27, 2008 4:59 AM PDT
There may be install/remove applications in the control panel in Windows, but the same can be said about them: not all of these completely remove files from your computer.

I'd still prefer the way Mac apps are installed. It's cleaner than how Windows does things. When you drag an app to the application folder, the files are installed there. Combined with an uninstaller menitioned above, the whole install/uninstall process is better than Windows.

I've been using AppTrap for close to a year now. No problems whatsoever.
Reply to this comment
by iertry July 27, 2008 7:09 AM PDT
Also have a look at AppDelete which I use. It seems to do a pretty good job and as far as I remember it's free. Usually I just drag the icon to the trash though.
Reply to this comment
by garybc12 July 28, 2008 1:08 PM PDT
I use AppDelete also. works great on my Mac. :)
by Dalmatian28 July 27, 2008 1:54 PM PDT
Why are this people here so defensive????? The man was trying to show you how clean your junk from computer and you are for what ever reason jumping to defend MAC OS. Nobody said anything about OSX being worst than windows or better than widows, all he wanted to show you is how to avoid piling up unnecessary garbage!!!! Another problem is that some of you need to get your facts straight! Some of the files left after installation are a lot bigger then just 4 kb. (egz. Adobe ) If you use it for couple years...it does add up! When it comes to spelling, anyone that uses Firefox that has been taken care of! Please stop acting like children and fight about which OS is better! They all have advantages and disadvantages. I have Apple notebook but run Vista on my desktop. It is best of the both worlds! My laptop is more mobile, runs two OS. While my desktop is a lot more powerful and faster (overclocked, better video) and runs great. I do tech-support for living and I got to tell you...I receive a lot more calls for OSX per unit than I do for windows. So grow up and realize that they both have advantages as well as disadvantages! How good each of the OS's are depends on what you trying to accomplish! That is why I own both of them!
Reply to this comment
by ebowdish July 28, 2008 5:48 PM PDT
I agree. Mac folk can get so defensive about their precious computers.
by Pete July 30, 2008 12:52 PM PDT
@Dalmation,
where is the defensiveness? People are just pointing out that the remaining files with present day hard disks are not such an issue anymore be they 4 kb or 40 kb, but if you're a tidy person these apps can be useful albeit not perfect. ALL of them still miss out on picking up crud left behind and will improve over time, what updates and upgrades are supposed to do.
As to Jason's remark:
"On a Windows machine, you can go to the control panel and choose the Add/Remove programs tool to find and uninstall software you don't want. But on a Mac, it's not as easy. When you install on a Mac the process usually involves dragging the software into your Applications folder. What you may not know is other files associated with that program are automatically installed into different folders to make the program work properly. So if you simply drag that app icon to the trash, you're leaving a significant amount of unused files on your hard drive"

Jason is a nice guy and finds almost every software he mentions nice without giving an in-depth review. So, being not easily shaken - and being a Mac and PC user - myself, I even find this remark odd coming from a nice Mac user, when I see how much crap, let alone crud, remains behind in a Windows machine that slows your system down as well, which I have never encountered with my Mac having over 300 (sic) applications on board!
Dumping an app in the trash still beats having to go in the uninstall procedure on a Windows box!
by anhtney July 28, 2008 3:34 AM PDT
lol :)
Reply to this comment
by jake49 July 28, 2008 9:05 AM PDT
why is everyone commenting bagging on each others OS? Mac and Windows are both good... Anyways the method for removing apps worked well on my mac...
Reply to this comment
by Pete July 31, 2008 8:44 AM PDT
@Dalmation,
where is the defensiveness? People are just pointing out that the remaining files with present day hard disks are not such an issue anymore be they 4 kb or 40 kb, but if you're a tidy person these apps can be useful albeit not perfect. ALL of them still miss out on picking up crud left behind and will improve over time, what updates and upgrades are supposed to do.
As to Jason's remark:
"On a Windows machine, you can go to the control panel and choose the Add/Remove programs tool to find and uninstall software you don't want. But on a Mac, it's not as easy. When you install on a Mac the process usually involves dragging the software into your Applications folder. What you may not know is other files associated with that program are automatically installed into different folders to make the program work properly. So if you simply drag that app icon to the trash, you're leaving a significant amount of unused files on your hard drive"

Jason is a nice guy and finds almost every software he mentions nice without giving an in-depth review. So, being not easily shaken - and being a Mac and PC user - myself, I even find this remark odd coming from a nice Mac user, when I see how much crap, let alone crud, remains behind in a Windows machine that slows your system down as well, which I have never encountered with my Mac having over 300 (sic) applications on board!
Dumping an app in the trash still beats having to go in the uninstall procedure on a Windows box!
Reply to this comment
(13 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next

Search Download Blog posts

advertisement
mySimon Outdoor Gear mySimon Swimwear mySimon Home and Garden

About The Download Blog

Download.com editors cover the world of downloadable software and beyond.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Download Blog topics