• On MovieTome: First Look: Jessica Alba in 'Machete'!
February 13, 2008 5:09 PM PST

Killer Download: The Big Three free security applications

by Jason Parker
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 271 comments
Killer Download (Credit: CNET Networks)

As users of the Internet we face security threats every day. Nefarious hackers (not all hackers), viruses, and spyware are rampant when online, and not taking precautions can mean lost data or even worse, identity theft. Frankly, if your computer is unprotected, you are rolling the dice every time you go online. Certainly many users already know this and are already using trusted software, or have other security measures in place to ensure safe surfing. This Killer Download is for those who don't or anyone who has questions regarding their safety online.

Whenever I get a new system or get the call to "fix" a friends computer (which more often than not is infected with some sort of system-slowing malware), I always download software from the security categories I refer to as The Big Three. The Big Three includes an antivirus program, an antispyware program, and a software-based firewall. There are certainly other, even safer methods (like using a secure external router instead of a software firewall), but most people can surf safely with these three program types on their system. At the bare minimum, every Windows user should have The Big Three covered.

There are several applications you can buy to fulfill these needs, but there are plenty of free alternatives which will keep you just as safe. Clearly, if your information is of the national security variety, or the plans for a working time machine, you may want to consider higher-end methods for protecting your data. But if you're just a regular computer user who surfs the Web, plays online games, downloads software, or does some occasional banking and bill paying online, this Killer Download is for you.

I should point out my favorites change as I find and test new applications, and you may have an even better solution to use as one of your Big Three. If so, make certain to let us know in the comments so we can all benefit. Here are my current Top 3 free applications I use at home.

Comodo Firewall Pro

The summary screen lets you know your firewall is up to date and operational.

(Credit: CNET Networks)

Comodo Firewall Pro offers solid protection against threats by learning your computing habits and what applications you use. This way, if something out of the ordinary occurs, you'll get a notification giving you the option to block suspicious connections to your computer. The interface is easy to understand and guides you through the setup process to make sure you're protected. It's important to note that you will get a lot of notifications in the beginning as Comodo Firewall learns your habits. However, after awhile a window might pop-up which seems suspicious and you'll be glad you have the ability to lock out a potential threat. As an alternative, the free version of ZoneAlarm Firewall is another solid firewall.

Spyware Terminator

Use the tabbed interface to get to all of this applications features.

(Credit: CNET Networks)

Spyware Terminator is my current favorite for antispyware applications. It has a slick interface, performs relatively fast scans, and includes free real-time protection. So many antispyware demos scan, but don't remove malware before you pay the registration, or they do scan and remove, but the real-time protection is locked. Spyware Terminator has all the features of the paid applications, but it's absolutely free. One word of caution: I'm not fully sold on the real-time protection in Spyware Terminator because it seems to notify me a lot, even to the point of repeat notifications. Whether you choose to have real-time protection on or off, if you stick to a scan schedule, this application will keep your system clean. Another great alternative is the ever popular Ad-Aware 2007, but you won't get the real-time protection without paying.

AntiVir PersonalEdition Classic

Check this summary screen often to make sure you're up to date.

(Credit: CNET Networks)

Avira AntiVir PersonalEdition rounds out my Big Three with solid antivirus protection at no cost. This reliable application quickly scans drives for every form of virus, trojan, and worm, letting you delete or quarantine anything it finds. It lets you focus your search to specific types of scans, and select drives if you have a hunch about a particular problem. This application also offers a real-time guard, so you can stop a virus before it takes root. Like any antivirus program (or antispyware program for that matter) AntiVir will only remain a contender if they keep updating their virus definitions, and so far they are perfect. Your alternative for the third slot of The Big Three is the well known AVG Anti-Virus Free Edition which is definitely worthy of any home computer security system.

If you don't have a program which fits each of these three security types, download and install them now. Though no security system can be foolproof, once you have the Big Three covered on your home computer, you'll be able to surf much more safely.

Jason Parker writes software reviews and features for Windows, Mac, and iPhone. If he learned to dance, it would make him a fabled "quadruple threat," but we can't get him to do it.
Recent posts from The Download Blog
Tell the time and destroy the Death Star: iPhone Apps of the week
Windows Starter Kit refreshed for 2010
Big changes in Security Starter Kit 2010
Why to embrace Firefox 3.6's new-tab ethos
Sale: CoPilot Live GPS for iPhone, $19.99
Three apps we're thankful for
Mozilla issues near-final Thunderbird 3
eBay opens auction app for BlackBerry
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 11 pages (271 Comments)
by new61 February 13, 2008 8:17 PM PST
I agree with you completely. Spyware Terminator is a excelent free program!
I dont like ad-aware, or any other spyware remover more then Spyware terminator.
Reply to this comment
by glcop February 16, 2008 5:58 PM PST
Spyware Terminator is good but it now has a toolbar they beg you to install.
SUPERantispyware and A-Squared Free 3.1 have better detection and removal.
by algreig2 February 20, 2008 5:01 PM PST
You have got to be joking! All this stuff is so "last century". Why persist with all the extra crapware, just to be able to survive. Get Mandriva Linux, and kiss hackers, viruses, and stability issues good-bye. Haven't used a virus scanner on Linux since I switched 8 years ago. Have never been hacked. And I can do everything I need. I choose not to play murder and mayhem type games. So I have no need for the dark side of the force.
by lplayter August 15, 2008 10:17 PM PDT
Thank You for the thumbs up on spyware terminator.I use it and was impressed but could not find many other enthusiasts for it around the net.
by knight6230 February 14, 2008 2:12 AM PST
i think that zone alarm security suite is a perfect program for the three security types and i agree with you about your apps they are all great but i did not try comodo
but i can say that AVG Anti-Virus Free Edition, Avira AntiVir PersonalEdition, and Ad-Aware 2007 are must have programs with any security program that you use
Reply to this comment
by rosiemyrosie February 20, 2008 8:06 PM PST
I understand you to say use both the AVG anti-Virus and the Avira Anti-Virus? It has been my understanding you can run multiple spy-ware programs simultaneously, but should only run one Anti-Virus program at a time? I would very much like to know if this is true and should be the practice.

As for the free ware, I entirely agree with the article. I have used different internet security suites from several top rated suppliers. Finally got fed up with cost, problems and lack of tauted tech support, So went back to the free-ware. Very satisfied and no problems to speak of. I use Zone Alarm firewall, Avast Anti-virus, Spy ware Terminator, all very fine products. Also, use Ad-Aware which is often a problem downloading the updates. Additionally, use Window Defenders, which is quietly in the background, so who really knows if it works?

There are three (3) free wares that CNET recommended earlier this year, CCleaner, Advanced Windows Care, and Disc Defrag Auslogics. You gotta have these. Fast, fast scans for cleaning up everything left from a surfing session. I run CCleaner and Advanced Windows Care every night before I close down my computer. Never been happier and my computer never ran better. Based on the responses in this article may try the Avira Anti-spy ware program, thus my question about running two anti-virus programs simultaneously.

Lastly, I receive many tech news letter and without a doubt CNet is top of the heap. Good information, easy to understand and relevant for the regular computer user. I really count on these guys to discuss things relevant to my needs.
by rosiemyrosie February 20, 2008 8:24 PM PST
P.S.
Forgot to mention the one and only, WinPatrol from BillP Studios. They have a free version and a PLUS version, one time payment for the full meal deal, or simply enjoy the free version. This is a fantastic little program that will keep you informed of everything running on your computer. Windows Task Manager on steroids with enhanced capability. Guarantee you won't be disappointed. Try the free version for a while.
by relfstro February 20, 2008 8:54 PM PST
I bought Zone Alarm and three days later, my computer wouldn't load at all. I finally finessed it into safe mode so I could remove it. My computer was back to it's normally fantastic operation. $50 bucks down the tubes. I'll stick with Norton. If you build a good enough box, you wont have to worry about resources. Amen
by mrlemarquis February 20, 2008 11:41 PM PST
Due to some recent events, I've added a 4th and 5th "must" - AVG Free Rootkit detector and AVG Free Antispy.
by Little Miss Nemesis February 14, 2008 2:37 AM PST
Some good choices. But I've made some recent changes to my security applications, both of which I'm very happy with. Spyware Terminator's real time protection, while good, was using way too much of my memory, so I substituted it for the free version of SpyCatcher, which is using less memory and has caught two spyware that I'm not certain would have been discovered by Spyware Terminator, which only appeared to be finding cookies.

I also -after being a long time user- have swapped from Avast to Avira. The scans are much faster and the resources that have been freed up is spectacular. Avast had five or six processes running and was using over 50,000K of memory. Avira, on the other hand, only seems to have two processes running and is using slightly more than 10,000K.

And to keep things extra secure, scanning once a week with Trend Micro Housecall keeps my system nice and clean.
Reply to this comment
by alice_b0wie February 14, 2008 3:28 AM PST
i guess if you want your computer to run as slow as possible, have countless security pop-ups and you have a monthly budget of $0 these are perfect for you. although avira is a good choice, it's smooth operation is ruined by the other two.
Reply to this comment
by GhostAlph May 4, 2008 6:59 AM PDT
...thanks for offering alternatives to the readers. Much appreciated.
by rom_eon February 14, 2008 4:28 AM PST
I use almost the same programs. Instead of Avira I prefer Avast, but that is just a matter of taste. To complete my protection arsenal I also use Theat Fire, SpywareCatcher and occasionally Ad-Aware for scanning my PC.

Regards from France
Reply to this comment
by Alan Snow February 21, 2008 1:08 AM PST
I also am a fan of Avast. It is a neat system and seems to bw doing its job very nicely.
by ak6328 July 7, 2008 4:03 PM PDT
by playtom February 14, 2008 9:30 AM PST
Comodo in my mind is one of the best firewalls available, while spyware terminator is quite good, i would prefer spybot because it use less resource and has more advanced features. For anti-virus i don't trust any of the freebies, because they don't have advanced herustic detection and they don't stand up to the big guys like norton or nod32.

I only use comodo and occasionally spybot to protect my computer, add in a secure browser like opera or firefox and you're safefully protected. I am a power user and i am fully aware of how to prevent virus and remove them in case i need to. So far, it's been almost two years since i've encountered a virus. I might try vista for an OS in the near future because i think they have the way more security features, and it would save you from installing a couple extra security apps.
Reply to this comment
by JoyceNgo-218335993631273378369 February 14, 2008 10:17 AM PST
I agree but I don't agree with the user who said ZoneAlarm is a excellent security suite. I used to have it and I was very happy with it since it had a three-way protection of spyware, viruses and a firewall, however they never mentioned low memory usage, so my computer was VERY VERY slow when running ZoneAlarm, it has quite a few processes and uses a lot of memory! With kaspersky Antivirus/Internet Suite or Avast running, ZoneAlarm used about 200MB RAM more. It was a major disappointment because the product itself is so good, but the memory usage is not.
Reply to this comment
by Chinookman February 20, 2008 6:22 PM PST
Another negative to Zone Alarm is that over a period of three years I have tried to use thier program and each time it resulted in a 'Vector Engine' problem and it was then an issue so I will not say never use it I will never recommend that product among other issues already mentioned. Thank you guys for the comodo...reco..
by sikyo February 14, 2008 11:50 AM PST
I agree with most of what's in this article, as well as other comments by your subscribers. i would also suggest checking out AV-comparatives.org to see how the best AV's compare with others and matousec.com for the same about firewalls, the results there might surprise a lot of people! Favorite security apps of some may not be that good as previously thought. I myself use Avira Antivir Personal Edition Classic (freeware, with heuristics, sorry), Comodo Firewall Pro, currently testing Spyware Doctor Starter Edition (in place of Spyware Terminator which is ok but runs about 50MB of processes, maybe not good for slower comps), SpywareBlaster and Spybot - Search and Destroy (with Teatimer disabled to save on resources) as well as some other apps as backup and a few utilities for maintenance. Spyware Doctor though causes some items in the protected list of SpywareBlaster and Spybot to be disabled, requiring enabling whenever the app is started. All apps are daily updated and other tweaks (browser settings, java, etc) are done, which combined with good surfing habits, has kept our comp pest free. I believe it's possible to roll out a security suite using freewares that would rival, if not be better than well-known paid suites out there, thanks to sites like CNET, majorgeeks, and others where articles and clean downloads abound. another very good firewall is Online Armor Free, with less decisions for the user but I had a few problems running some apps with it, unlike Comodo which works well with just about every app. Nothing beats Avira Antivir's antivermin and AV protection among freeware, even rivalling paid versions of other well known apps. Hope these helps!
Reply to this comment
by Drezen February 15, 2008 7:00 AM PST
I would add SpywareBlaster to make a Big Four. It's an excellent app that stops spyware from getting on to your system in the first place and it works so well that I very rarely finds anything with Ad-Aware. It's completely free, but a small fee unlocks the very useful auto update feature.
Reply to this comment
by cdharris February 15, 2008 8:46 AM PST
Do I really need Comodo or another firewall if I am running the Windows Firewall that is included with XP?
Reply to this comment
by westc661 February 15, 2008 10:12 PM PST
The firewall that comes with XP provides absolutely no protect at all!! You can go here and read for yourself:

http://www.firewallleaktester.com/tests.php

If you connect to the internet, you will definitely need a good firewall and anti-virus program that is up to date. If your unwilling to dish out a few bucks for a top notch program, you can go here to find the top free apps.

http://www.techsupportalert.com/best_46_free_utilities.htm

Good Luck!
by billk11 February 16, 2008 9:18 AM PST
I, too would like an answer to this question. Thanks for asking it
by criztopha February 16, 2008 4:18 PM PST
No, you do not need an additional software firewall. It does offer extra security, but it's the least mandatory of the "Big Three"
by glcop February 16, 2008 5:56 PM PST
XP firewall is a 1 way firewall. It helps stop things from breaking into your computer. If something does get on your computer it will not stop things from leaving your computer. Comodo and many of the other firewalls are 2 way firewalls.
It is best to run a 2 way firewall. That is what Vista has now.
by TheTechKid February 17, 2008 7:28 PM PST
I personally use the the standard Vista Premium Firewall, Windows Defender and Symantec Antivirus or AVG Antivirus Free Edition. I never have any issues.
by nikhilnaidu February 17, 2008 8:23 PM PST
Well, lemme put it this way, the windows firewall is like a screen door with a soft curtain so that people cannot peep in. Whereas, the other firewalls are like safety doors made of steel. unless you allow someone to enter by opening it, it is absolutely safe. So go ahead use a good firewall.
Also all windows firewalls, work using the SVHost protocol and it is as easy to disable it (externally) as it would be to sit on the PC and do it.
by rbsjrx February 20, 2008 5:08 PM PST
MS Windows firewall is a joke! In test after test, it has proven to be the last effective firewall available. I use the commercial version of Zone Alarm security suite, but Comod is also good for folks unwilling or unable to pay for Zone Alarm.
by moviegeek65 February 20, 2008 8:56 PM PST
Windows Defender is worthless,use Ad-Aware or SuperAntiSpyware for real-time protection.
by rosiemyrosie February 20, 2008 9:03 PM PST
This is a fantastic site for the free 46 you recommended. Thanks much.
by mediawork February 21, 2008 4:55 AM PST
You definitely need another firewall. I relied on Windows XP Firewall, had my C Drive badly corrupted, and had to replace it at high expense. No such problems after some years of Zone Alarm Free.
See more comment replies
by markdoiron February 15, 2008 9:05 AM PST
Yes, I should think so. While the Windows XP firewall provides some protection from attacks outside your computer, once something gets into your computer, it provides no protection to that something connecting to the Internet and passing on whatever--password lists, credit card numbers, e-mail addresses, etc. It also provides no protection should your computer become a drone/zombie for some malicious program. For more info, read here:

http://www.andyrathbone.com/tips/twoway.html
Reply to this comment
by gmennino February 15, 2008 9:12 AM PST
People - Get Zone Alarm Pro or Trend-Micro. Yeah you pay for them, but they're about as good as it gets for complete PC protection. Regarding AVG and Avast - I've seen these programs miss viruses completely. I used to be a fan of AVG and Avast until I saw both of them them miss Trojans. Ouch! Well - you ask - How did I find out? I did a freeby trend-micro scan of my pc. Jason Parker - c'mon fess up - who's paying who for these product pumps?
Reply to this comment
by scmesser February 15, 2008 5:25 PM PST
Why not just stick with a great suite like Symantecs 360. Covers most of the bases as well, but yes there is a cost?
by mrwilhite February 20, 2008 5:08 PM PST
Bingo! Gemennino! You hit the nail on the head, you get what you pay for! I have been using the Trend for over the past 7 years. Smaller memory footprint, configurable & accurate. As a tech with over 30 years of experience, I have found that none work better. One of my pet peeves is the customer who wants to use all this FREE software. I will not install such software on thier computer. I do not want them mad at me when they have to bring it back for damage control. Spend thousands on a new computer and run free a/v? I don't think so. I would however use Avast or AVG over Norton or McAffee.
by Bruce Myers February 20, 2008 5:18 PM PST
I couldn't agree more about Zone Alarm. I've been using Zone Alarm Suite for years now and I haven't had even one problem. I use my USB drives at my school and am constantly getting infected by doing so. As soon as I plug them into my computer, Zone Alarm immediately deals with them.

Bruce
by musicollector February 20, 2008 8:26 PM PST
Hmmm...I am using AVG. Now, I am concerned. I think the question should have been, "what are the three best Anti-Trojan freeware apps"?? So, what IS the best choice for preventing Trojans since you say AVG did not work? I am not sure I trust those "free" online scans which gives you a free scan and then gets you by the throat at the end - pay up or else!
by musicollector February 20, 2008 9:07 PM PST
Okay - I had missed that. I see Avira is the one I need for trojans. :)
by rsawoseyin February 20, 2008 10:06 PM PST
I ditched Trend-Micro 3 years ago when, having bought a 1-year subscription in the U.S. and I travelled overseas, it would not allow a renewal of the subscription overseas. I guess those folks were paranoid about piracy.
by DADSGETNDOWN February 20, 2008 11:33 PM PST
Ofcourse those are good.
BUT.
this (gmennino), should realize that we can produce trojans, spyware, Virii and whatever else that one program free or not will miss and another will catch, (no matter who they are).
IF you look you will find MANY other knowledgeable, people and techs alike who say why go paid when you get as good or better with some free apps.

(musicollector) the free online Housecall by Trendmicro IS GREAT! and does NOT ask you tp pay before you fix, they do have a paid version yes.
(there are atleast 3 other good ones online).

You should know whether you have a paid or free versions of anything.
you MUST use more than one spyware catcher/remover.
only one antivirus intsalled on a computer, although you use free scans to suppliment that.
by musicollector February 21, 2008 8:05 AM PST
So, DADSGETNDOWN, here is my question. I have been using the fabulous AVG AV software all these years, with no problems. Should I go with Avira AntiVir Personal Edition, or stick with AVG? I sort of get nervous when I read that AVG missed some trojans. You mentioned that no software will catch them all, but in the overall scheme of things, which one would YOU go for? TIA.
by wahabam February 15, 2008 9:48 AM PST
I use AVG and COMODO...I have to say that for free software they definitely have MORE than enough bang for the buck that I didn't spend. They don't bog down my system at all. I got sick of the McAfee's and Norton's of the world...since they REALLY ate up my computer resources. If these programs eat up your resources...I think there might be something else going on in your system. I'm a stand by SpyBot...probably because I've used it for years now...and I have NOT have any problems with it at all. I use limewire...and I have NOT have any issues with spyware/malware/ETC....
Reply to this comment
by Mileen February 20, 2008 9:19 PM PST
My computer deleted Spybot when I downloaded Adware alert, both of them disapeared??
by Enigmaasdf February 15, 2008 10:16 AM PST
For a clean pc:
Threatfire will pretty much block most spyware.
Comodo is a great light-weight software firewall. Perfect for laptops when your outside your home network.
Nod32 - best AV period.
Reply to this comment
by CrimsonFox February 15, 2008 10:40 AM PST
Comodo, Avira and Spyware Terminator were the three greatest gifts that I gave my PC.
Reply to this comment
by FalseToU February 29, 2008 2:47 PM PST
Take a look at Spywareblaster. Spyware Terminator installed a "crawler" toolbar on my pc that behaved just like spyware. Popping up constantly to warn me everytime doubleclick wanted to install (Spywareblaster has managed to keep it off all this time without aggravating me about it every single time.)
by cpeterka February 15, 2008 11:44 AM PST
I like a combination of the Freebee SPYBOT and the pay for it AD-Aware.
I usually pop the Spybot guy 20 bucks via paypal, just 'cause I feel guilty that such a great program is free.
Reply to this comment
by fisherperson February 15, 2008 1:02 PM PST
I have CA SECURITY SUITE and go to sites all over the world. Took some doing to set it up to the right peramiters. ca tech assistance. Have not had any thing at all after it was set right. Does your security system help pay for your computer?Do they have insurance against identy theft due to hackers? 24/7online help?
Reply to this comment
by Mileen February 20, 2008 9:20 PM PST
If they understand english! I bought this and have never used it!!
by cedmondson February 21, 2008 12:44 AM PST
Fisherperson...I am a network engineer with 20 years exp, and I can tell you that CA A/V products, especially E-Trust A/V, simply do not work. The reason you don't get a lot of alerts is because the products miss so much. Our corp was a CA customer, until I loaded TrendMicro OfficeScan on one of my test computers. It immediately caught 23 items that CA had missed outright. I went back (with Ghost images) and re-ran the test. Same result...even after running a full scan by CA right before loading TM, CA would find nothing and then TM would find the same 23 infections once loaded. This is the benefit of having a testing lab. (This is user-level protection I am reviewing...we have different products for server & network level protection).
by alex_mayorga February 15, 2008 2:33 PM PST
Just install a solid OS, namely anything *nix based, and forget about all this. I've personally done it and never looked back. As usual YMMV.
Reply to this comment
by skater_66 February 21, 2008 9:18 AM PST
amen brother, i uninstalled all of this crap 4 years ago and i never looked back. the only things i do with micro$oft boxes anymore is if they're win xp make sure they have sp2 and defender and enable the firewall and let updates download automatically. that's it and god knows this pc has been down every seedy alley in the world. oh yeah, firefox over IE is another key to intrusion free computing.
by aintnorainbowdorothy February 15, 2008 3:47 PM PST
I too am a power user, use Vista Ultimate with XP Pro on the same computer. One thing I learned a long time ago is that too many cooks spoil the soup and that goes for multiple AV, Firewall and so on. Use a good paid anti-virus, not CA nor Norton both of which are system hogs. I use Trend-Micro, although as a disclaimer I do Beta work for them. But I used Trend before I began doing Beta work for them. More than one good
AV, etc. is bad, bad, bad. Multiple programs of the sort find each other as a virus, and want to remove it. Perhaps that's what some of those AV programs are finding. Use just one and get off your wallet. And it doesn't matter which OS you use, Microsoft, Safari, Linux (yes the various versions do get malware), Google or even one you write for yourself. You get what you pay for. Get a good program and pay for it. You will find out you'r better off for it.
Reply to this comment
by bprettyc February 15, 2008 7:10 PM PST
Dear Jason!
Amazing! I got the 3 killer-diller's and ran them and with the System Restore turned off!! One found 2 Heur/Exploits in my Recovery Drive which means that everytime I reinstalled my computer I reinstalled those as well. I was told last year when we bought the computer in Jan. 07, that sometimes "creeps" will mess with the computer before it is put in the box. I had trouble with this thing since we set up, had a period of time until November 07 where it looked like it was ok. That's when I got hit by a PswdBnkr Virus, 2 dozen Remkills and 6 Trojans btw. November 07 and last week! If I hadn't found you I would still be guessing! As it is, I get to buy new CD;s from HP to restore my computer and I'm ditzing Mcafee that should have found all of this by now!! Where is a good place to back up graphics, photos and artwork?
Thanks so very much! bdscochran/VA/USA
Reply to this comment
by mrwilhite February 20, 2008 5:16 PM PST
With a system that new, you should have a CDRW or DVDRW. Depending on size I would burn them to one or the other. You also have thumbdrive, external HD or remote storage.
by Mileen February 20, 2008 9:21 PM PST
With an external hard drive.
Showing 1 of 11 pages (271 Comments)

Search Download Blog posts

About The Download Blog

Download.com editors cover the world of downloadable software and beyond.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Download Blog topics