• On MovieTome: First Look: Jessica Alba in 'Machete'!
The Download Blog
advertisement
November 30, 2007 6:07 PM PST

Can you defrag your registry?

by Seth Rosenblatt
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 16 comments

Auslogics, publisher of the popular Auslogics Disk Defrag, also makes another defragger: Registry Defrag. Does it actually work? Is it all smoke and mirrors, or does using this free program result in faster clock times?

The empirical, Friday afternoon answer is: it's hard to tell. If that sounds familiar to those of you who've used other registry cleaners and their siblings, it should. It's hard to gauge if these programs are effective because once you're done using it, you'd need more than a mere store-bought machine with store-loaded programs to judge CPU speed by.

It's much harder to gauge the effectiveness of registry cleaners than disk fixers.

Regardless of its effectiveness, the Auslogics Registry Defrag looks and functions much like the Auslogics Disk Defrag. When you run it, it tells you that it will perform a registry analysis, after which you will be able to review its registry report, and once that's done with you can run the registry optimization, requiring a reboot to defrag and compact the registry.

It's a fairly serious program, and once you begin the analysis it won't let you move the mouse outside the program window. It also "strongly recommends" that users close all other programs while it runs, although this is a standard warning for registry cleaning apps.

Empirically, Disk Defrag seems to have an effect on performance.

After having run the program on my main work machine, a Windows XP box that sees an average of four to six programs installed and then uninstalled per day, not to mention having an average of two dozen Firefox tabs open, a registry sweeper should make the computer run faster. Even though I run disk defraggers a couple of times a week and keep a vigilant watch on resources, I expected an empirical yet noticeable change in CPU speed.

That never materialized. Resource-intensive programs like Internet browsers and e-mail clients may be piggish, but they're necessary. They didn't load any faster or slower than normal after running the reg defrag. It may be that I'll only notice after a few days or so, but until a registry defragger or cleaner can demonstrate benchmarkable improvements to a computer, they'll be little more than 21st century snake oil.

Seth peers into the deep, dark corners of software so that you don't have to. He has yet to suffer a single nightmare about OS/2. You can follow him on Twitter.
Recent posts from The Download Blog
Tell the time and destroy the Death Star: iPhone Apps of the week
Windows Starter Kit refreshed for 2010
Big changes in Security Starter Kit 2010
Why to embrace Firefox 3.6's new-tab ethos
Sale: CoPilot Live GPS for iPhone, $19.99
Three apps we're thankful for
Mozilla issues near-final Thunderbird 3
eBay opens auction app for BlackBerry
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (16 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by najaooshah December 1, 2007 7:55 AM PST
NICE
Reply to this comment
by Cchurch08 December 1, 2007 9:42 AM PST
I love Auslogics Disk Defrag, but Auslogics Registry Defrag? Hard to tell, but I'm siding with "no." After running it, I didn't see any change in speed with CPU responsiveness, but what I did see were bugs-seemed like various programs and functions on my laptop weren't running well or at all. Luckily it created a system restore point before it ran and I was able to roll back my system, followed by some hours of troubleshooting to get my old computer back. MonthsForever.blogspot.com
Reply to this comment
by Pcfreakske2000 December 2, 2007 5:56 AM PST
I use Auslogics Disk Defrag and Auslogics Registry Defrag since a while and I must say that it works very well.

Those two applications keep my computer in a perfect performance condition.

I don't use them much, only when I experience that my computer is running a bit slower than usual.

These applications are a must have for every computer user.
Reply to this comment
by jscott418 December 2, 2007 5:44 PM PST
Computers are so fast today that minor improvements like disk defrag and similar software due little to make a obvious improvement. Best thing to due is keep programs you don't need off your drive and defrag hard drive every month or so. If that much.
Reply to this comment
by TARADO69 December 3, 2007 8:34 AM PST
o.k.
Reply to this comment
by Bill Veik December 3, 2007 9:29 AM PST
You are not going to see an appreciable difference in speed with regards to Auslogices Registry Defrag. Nor are you going to see an enlargement in your free space.

As you install and remove programs, change settings, etc. you are creating registry entries. These bits and settings remain in your registry long after software is changed or removed.

They sit there, even if they are just empty folders. Problem is, your CPU is looking in those folders for information it needs to run every operation in the computer. 100 empty folders, 100 useless empty things to look in during every move your computer makes.

The speed you gain is not processor speed, or application speed. It is a reduction in the amount of time (in MS) that the computer takes to access the Windows Registry.
Reply to this comment
by lokotex December 3, 2007 1:42 PM PST
look at this tutorial to speed up your pc

http://webmaster360.org/How-To/Win-XP-Tweaks-using-Regedit.html
Reply to this comment
by david25mh December 3, 2007 7:22 PM PST
yess
Reply to this comment
by 6Cra6Zy6 December 4, 2007 4:16 AM PST
disk defrag is actually very important...though access times keep decreasing (larger rpm), capacity also increases which cancels any improvement at all. As the capacity increases the read heads will have to travel even more, which in the long run may get damaged. With fragmentation, the head may have to make hundreds of circles around the disk per second (exagerated) and most people believe that fragmentation is not such a serious matter but i have known some friends whose computers are better than mine but still mine runs faster. This is because they tend to copy all sort of files on their disks which they will never use. Some even blame programs to slow down their computers but there is no proof. This is because they have too much files stored on the disks that it increases access time which affects performance.

But however, i have not yet found a good defragmenter since they have some sort of weird programming that you have no real control over them. e.g:you cannot manually choose where you would want the files to be on the disk's surface.
Reply to this comment
by natalia December 4, 2007 3:19 PM PST
I have both these applications and use the hard disk one weekly and the registry one monthly.

After defraging with this application, I sometimes get a slight sluggishness occur and freeze-ups have also result both upon start-up and while surfing, too. Luckily, on next startup, the problem seems to resolve itself, but you can't be sure it's always going to.

Two years or so ago, I was using another brand of registry defrag,
of which I can't recall the name. The first half dozen defraggings showed no apparent ill-effects then an unexpected slow-up occurred
which was so severe, I had to do a full recovery of the operating system. Sometime later, I used it again, being not quite sure if it really was it that caused the need for the last recovery. I soon found out it was when a second recovery was needed.

My advise: Use ANY registry defrag sparingly and with caution. An application called ERUNT, although an old piece of software, has an Optimizer included, but no defrag. I often use that with no ill-effects.
Reply to this comment
by natalia December 4, 2007 3:39 PM PST
If you click on 'run' and type regedit then click on 'edit' and 'search', you can remove all instances of orphan files and strings belonging to uninstalled programmes. This process will take twenty attempts or more before all are removed and a dialogue box comes up saying 'nothing found'.

Of course, it's necessary to carefully study the names of the files and strings thrown up by the search each time, before deleting.
Reply to this comment
by jason285centralst December 13, 2007 12:42 AM PST
Ok first of all what does run fast mean? Also, stop bragging about how you can read and edit a registry, the common end user will not know how to do this and may hurt the computer more than help it.
I offer these parameters for running fast:
1. Boot up time (no faster now than it was in the pentium I, II and III days with the released windows OS for that era. My laptop is a AMD turon 64x2 with 2 GB DDR RAM runing Vista premium...guess what I can still make a cup of coffee in the time it reboots to windows, and boot into windows (see below)
2. Boot in time, this has slowed waaaay down. Sure no your in windows but the start up is loading tons of un needed programs...most likely your antivirus is running an un-needed scan and all kinds of stupid things are launching such as windows up-date...
3. Program start up time - varies with the type of program, I would go with the time it takes to load Office pro program (word 2003/07, excel, powerpoint)
4. The benchmarking should be done with the Industry standard low, medium and high end desktop or laptop configurations offered by the big three HP, Dell, Levono (no an alienware box is not a industry standard SOHO user!!! darn geeks you serve no purpose to the general public showing off how much you can overclock).

Now lets roll that up into one metric called Fast. The fastest box i ever had was a Pentium III 333 with 128mb of ram running windows 95. Every office program just popped open in less than a second...the boot time was about 32 seconds....it was a general public box selling for about 1200 bucks at the time.
Reply to this comment
by russefl December 29, 2007 7:11 AM PST
I downloaded the registry defrag and after it finished scanning I tried to defrag. It crashed my computer and I had to format and reload the OS. Can't say anything good about it.
Reply to this comment
by lastcaravan January 7, 2008 9:16 AM PST
disc defrag is speed in a small system. reg defrag is speed and stability.As a veteren MEist and a new Vistivian speed is good stability better. disc defrag weekly, reg defrag/clean up infrequently and gently with a mild cleaner/sorter. Leave the heavy cleaning to the geeks. Auslogic is well aimed at the semi-
knowlageable user.
Reply to this comment
by sensibility February 9, 2008 4:07 PM PST
playing with windows registry is dangerous folks just read how many have installed run and had to RE install the OS after the fact !!! its like the original author of this said "21st century snake oil" there is NO proof that it does any good !!!

*** "install what you NEED everything else is hog feed" ***
Reply to this comment
by martinex April 7, 2008 2:40 AM PDT
Anyone who uses a program that changes their registry without first backing up said registry deserves whatever horrible thing happens to them.
Reply to this comment
(16 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next

Search Download Blog posts

advertisement
Click Here

About The Download Blog

Download.com editors cover the world of downloadable software and beyond.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Download Blog topics