• On BNET: Vote: How will Apple blow it?
August 28, 2007 6:43 PM PDT

Running in a pack

by Seth Rosenblatt

The folks in Mountain View, Calif., have recently updated their Google Pack, and while combining some of the best programs with an automatic updater and installer, some of the program choices have left me disappointed. The recent addition of StarOffice confirms that while this collection is good, it could be a lot better.

The Google tools that are included are excellent, for the most part. Earth, Desktop, Talk, Picasa, the Google Photos Screensaver, and the Google Toolbar for Internet Explorer are all here for the program party.

Firefox is included, which is good. It comes bundled with the Google toolbar extension, which is unnecessary but easy enough to remedy. There's also Skype for text and voice chat and Spyware Doctor Starter Edition for malware detection and removal, but while the other programs included satisfy major food group requirements, there are healthier choices.

Painfully slow Adobe Reader could easily be replaced by the lightweight FoxIt Reader. Norton Security Scan is also cumbersome and large, and most users would be better served by AVG Anti-Virus or Avast Home Edition. StarOffice is the pay-for-play version of the OpenOffice suite, so why force people to spend money when there's a perfectly good freeware version to be had?

There are some important software areas that are missing from the pack, too. There used to be a universal chat application, but Trillian jumped ship almost a year ago. Pidgin would serve well. There's no archiving program, a niche that 7Zip could fill nicely, nor is there a registry cleaner, a rootkit killer, or a defragger. CCleaner, HiJack This, or Auslogics Disk Defrag, anyone? Somewhat shockingly, there's also no e-mail client--the Gmail-friendly Thunderbird would get my vote.

What strikes me as most unfortunate about the pack is that there aren't multiple choices in the same category. It's not out of the realm of possibility that Google has a financial investment in the programs it includes, but assuming they don't, it'd be great to have a more flexible pack.

If you could build your own auto-updating installer package, what would you include?

Seth peers into the deep, dark corners of software so that you don't have to. He has yet to suffer a single nightmare about OS/2. You can follow him on Twitter.
Recent posts from The Download Blog
Official NASA app and a hovercraft racing game: iPhone apps of the week
Popular iPhone movie app flops on BlackBerry
Must-have utilities for your Windows toolkit
Opera Mobile 10 beta browser: First Look video
Doom, Command & Conquer revived for iPhone
Mozilla's e-mail group looks toward the cloud
Seven essential free software apps for a new PC
Near-final Thunderbird 3 due next week
Add a Comment (Log in or register)
Pretty good article
by charlesrking August 29, 2007 12:56 AM PDT
I like your summary of the Google Pack, I do have one thing though - I was under the impression that the Staroffice offered in the Google Pack was free of charge; This is what has been said on various podcasts that I listen to (TWiT, Webbalert, DL.tv, Cranky Geeks).

Other than that I agree with your ideas, they definitely should have kept away from Norton and used one of the free alternatives like AVG or Avast! (I use Avast! myself); the lack of a multi-service IM client is kind of crazy too.
Reply to this comment

Search Download Blog posts

advertisement
Click Here

About The Download Blog

Download.com editors cover the world of downloadable software and beyond.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Download Blog topics