• On TechRepublic: Windows 7: Slower to boot than Vista?
June 25, 2009 4:20 PM PDT

Turn your iPhone into a home office

by Jessica Dolcourt

Up until last week, Quickoffice Mobile Office Suite was the most sophisticated Microsoft document reader and editor in the App Store. When Documents To Go came out (with and without support for Microsoft Exchange attachments,) some of you asked for a head-to-head comparison.

We'll see your request and raise it to a collection of business applications for the iPhone and iPod Touch that can help keep you productive at home or on the road.

Quickoffice versus Documents To Go

The starkest differences between Quickoffice Mobile Suite and Documents To Go boil down to price, file support, and interface. Both can view Word, Excel, PowerPoint, PDFs, and iWork documents. They are also able to transfer files via a USB drive hookup or through pairing over a Wi-Fi network.

In terms of image quality, both had commendably clear and faithful rendering of images and text. Both instances of Documents To Go are less expensive (at the time of writing) than Quickoffice; about $5 and $10 versus Quickoffice's Mobile Suite at $20. However, Documents To Go can only edit and create Word docs. Quickoffice can generate and edit Word and Excel files.

Quickoffice iPhone app

Editing tools are more easily accessible in Quickoffice.

(Credit: CNET/Screenshot by Jessica Dolcourt)

The Word-only editing limitation brings the standard Documents To Go app closer to the standalone Quickword product (iTunes link), also about $5 now that it's on sale (it's been dropped down from $13.) Quickoffice cannot create or edit Word or Excel 2007 files at present, but Documents To Go does support Word 2007 documents.

In terms of layout and usability, Quickoffice's menu systems are slightly easier to access and use than those on Documents To Go. However, Documents To Go's more premium app opens the door to reading attachments sent over Microsoft Exchange. It's got a trickier setup process than we'd like, but once that's been cleared away, the actual reading and saving are smooth.

For now, choosing the better of the two apps for your needs is a simple calculation. Those who actively work with Excel documents should stick with Quickoffice at this time. Those who rely more on reading e-mail attachments in their full glory (and especially editing the attached Word docs) should head for the premium version of Documents To Go. The set that mostly needs access to Word documents but rarely works with spreadsheets should let economic considerations guide them to the $5 version of Documents To Go.

However, since both applications have ambitious development schedules and strategies, the value proposition of each could rapidly change by the version number. We'll be keeping an eye on these as they continue to take their turns at bat.

See which applications made our top productivity picks for the iPhone and iPod Touch.

Corrected on June 26, 2009 at 2:45 p.m. PT: Documents To Go can edit and create Word 2007 documents.

Jessica Dolcourt reviews the latest and greatest smartphone apps, in addition to a healthy dose of Windows software. E-mail Jessica and follow her on Twitter.
Recent posts from The Download Blog
Panda's Cloud Antivirus leaves beta behind
Sneak peek: Xobni e-mail app for BlackBerry
Apple plugs holes for domain spoofing, other attacks
Paint.NET 3.5 earns Windows 7, stability fixes
Now on Download: Bigger, better screenshots!
VMware elevates its desktop virtualization view
After 5 years, Firefox faces new challenges
Shazam iPhone app gets premium Encore
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (10 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by Dan7637 June 25, 2009 5:04 PM PDT
if they add the word 07 support i would get this, thx for the tip
Reply to this comment
by J-Do June 26, 2009 8:24 AM PDT
Note that there is support to view the files. What neither has at this point is the ability to edit or create .docx file types. I agree, both these programs are only going to get better, and the competition between them should fuel the development.
by June 26, 2009 8:41 AM PDT
I bought DocsToGo on the iPhone the first week it was out and believe this article is inaccurate. DocsToGo DOES support .docx (Office 2007) Word files (editing and creating). in fact, in the app's settings you choose which version to create a new doc in (doc or docx). Did you try the app??? lastly, i don't think it's mentioned that Excel editing is promised as a free update from DataViz.
by J-Do June 26, 2009 2:44 PM PDT
You are right. Thank you for pointing that out. I've corrected the article to reflect that.
by Ironic_Commando June 25, 2009 5:19 PM PDT
@Quickoffice on Twitter has confirmed that the next version will support editing .docx and .xlsx files, and be able to pull files from email attachments.
Reply to this comment
by cabrillo24 June 26, 2009 4:48 AM PDT
I've prefered Documents 2 Go so far because it offers exchange support and will plan on integrating with the iPhone 3.0 software (i.e. copy and paste throughout all apps). I like the QuickOffice style a little more, but Documents 2 Go has been a lot more functional for someone such as myself who needs Exchange support.

I don't know why the author said Exchange setup was difficult, I set mine up in less than 30 seconds.
Reply to this comment
by J-Do June 26, 2009 8:33 AM PDT
Cabrillo24, glad the Exchange set-up worked well for you. I also had no issues, but a lot of users reported that they had trouble. It helps to know your Exchange settings. Not everyone does, especially if they don't have direct access to their corporate Exchange Server.
by downiphone June 26, 2009 12:39 PM PDT
I had Documents to Go on my Palm T|X and was looking for the same functionality on the iPhone which has replaced it. So far, I would say it's OK but it will be better when it can create and edit Excel files. The PDF reader is the built in iPhone one, which isn't too great at reading through long documents (like software manuals). I haven't tried QuickOffice so can't comment on that.

I haven't used copy and paste because I don't want to learn how Documents to Go does it and then unlearn it when the next update comes along and uses the inbuilt iPhone 3.0 copy and paste. A comment above suggests QuickOffice doesn't use this either but presumably they will in future because being able to copy into other apps and paste from them is an important feature.

Maybe someone with QuickOffice can say whether it does two things which Documents to Go doesn't: create a table in Word (if it can do this, I can't see how) and zoom the screen (same again - it seems to be stuck in one magnification). Of course once it has Excel editing, it will be easy enough to use that to create a tabular layout and enter data but I hope that zooms. I don't need Exchange sync because I am using it with a Mac for personal stuff.
Reply to this comment
by J-Do June 26, 2009 2:48 PM PDT
Docs To Go and Quickoffice both have their own cut 'n' paste. It's easy to pick up and both work similarly to each other. They also both say they will integrate the iPhone OS 3.0 version of cut and paste into their applications. It's a great feature with a pretty flat learning curve--you shouldn't have to wait for a version update to use it.
by hesiodsoftware July 4, 2009 6:48 AM PDT
Nice app but i don't think the iphone will be good enough to be a competitor of the pc .
Reply to this comment
(10 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next

Search Download Blog posts

advertisement

About The Download Blog

Download.com editors cover the world of downloadable software and beyond.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Download Blog topics